← All states & the national list

The Largest Property Management Companies in Indiana

The largest residential property management companies in Indiana, ranked by third-party doors under management. 17 companies listed, managing 17,575 doors combined.

17
Companies in Indiana
17,600+
Doors under management
937
Median doors

By third-party doors under management. Self-reported. SFR and small multifamily (under 100 units). = highest-ranking executive

#CompanyDoorsChange
from 2025
SoftwareStructuremembermemberCustomer
1
West Lafayette, IN·John Rabold, CEO
3,303N/AAppFolioDepartmentalNoNo
2
Indianapolis, IN·Traves Bonwell CEO
3,000N/AAppFolioDepartmentalNoNo
3
Indianapolis, IN·Joseph Atha, CEO
1,957N/ARentvinePod-Departmental HybridNo
4
Indianapolis, IN·Mark Jones - President
1,583N/ARentvineDepartmentalNo
5
Indianapolis, IN·Jeremy Tallman, CEO
1,225N/ARentvinePod-Departmental HybridNoNo
6
Anderson, IN·Nick Rodgers, Owner
1,017N/AAppFolioDepartmentalNoNo
7
Indianapolis, IN·Joel and Jennifer Wilmoth-Co-owners
985N/ARentvinePod-Departmental HybridNoNo
8
Fort Wayne, IN·Tammie Jones, CEO
985N/AAppFolioDepartmentalNoNoNo
9
Merrillville, IN·Brad Mistina, Managing Partner
937N/ARentvineDepartmentalNoNo
10
Kokomo, IN·Chris Mullinax, CEO, Managing Broker
780N/ARentvinePod-Departmental HybridNo
1
West Lafayette, IN·John Rabold, CEO
3,303doors
Change from 2025N/A
SoftwareAppFolio
StructureDepartmental
NARPMCraneBoom customer
2
Indianapolis, IN·Traves Bonwell CEO
3,000doors
Change from 2025N/A
SoftwareAppFolio
StructureDepartmental
NARPMCraneBoom customer
3
Indianapolis, IN·Joseph Atha, CEO
1,957doors
Change from 2025N/A
SoftwareRentvine
StructurePod-Departmental Hybrid
NARPMCraneBoom customer
4
Indianapolis, IN·Mark Jones - President
1,583doors
Change from 2025N/A
SoftwareRentvine
StructureDepartmental
NARPMCraneBoom customer
5
Indianapolis, IN·Jeremy Tallman, CEO
1,225doors
Change from 2025N/A
SoftwareRentvine
StructurePod-Departmental Hybrid
NARPMCraneBoom customer
6
Anderson, IN·Nick Rodgers, Owner
1,017doors
Change from 2025N/A
SoftwareAppFolio
StructureDepartmental
NARPMCraneBoom customer
7
Indianapolis, IN·Joel and Jennifer Wilmoth-Co-owners
985doors
Change from 2025N/A
SoftwareRentvine
StructurePod-Departmental Hybrid
NARPMCraneBoom customer
8
Fort Wayne, IN·Tammie Jones, CEO
985doors
Change from 2025N/A
SoftwareAppFolio
StructureDepartmental
NARPMCraneBoom customer
9
Merrillville, IN·Brad Mistina, Managing Partner
937doors
Change from 2025N/A
SoftwareRentvine
StructureDepartmental
NARPMCraneBoom customer
10
Kokomo, IN·Chris Mullinax, CEO, Managing Broker
780doors
Change from 2025N/A
SoftwareRentvine
StructurePod-Departmental Hybrid
NARPMCraneBoom customer

The rest of the Indiana list

  1. 11Mackie PropertiesBloomington, IN · CEO
  2. 12Baron Management GroupSouth Bend, IN · Brett Baron CEO
  3. 13A Step Ahead ManagementCarmel, IN · Chad Stickley, CEO
  4. 14MiddleTown Property GroupMuncie, IN · Dane Wilson, Co-owner, CEO
  5. 15PMI LafayetteLafayette, IN · Wendy Yuill President
  6. 16Resolute RDMIndianapolis, IN · Ryan Cadwell, CEO
  7. 17True Care PropertiesMishawaka, IN · Amy Bevier, CEO

Part of the 2026 national ranking of the largest residential PM companies.

See the rest of the country.

This is the Indiana cut of the national ranking of the largest residential PM companies.

The national list & every state